Sony Beats $2.6 Billion PlayStation Boss Fight Over Digital Game Prices

PlayStation 5 Console.
PlayStation 5 Console. Image: Sony.
Sony has notched an important legal win in the UK’s Competition Appeal Tribunal, which sided with the company in a lawsuit that alleged that its PlayStation digital store gave it a “monopoly position” regarding game distribution. With this legal victory it’s no longer on the hook for the $2.6 billion in compensation the plaintiffs were seeking for over 12 million of its customers.

The tribunal disagreed with the claim that Sony had any kind of monopoly over game sales, saying that there was “strong evidence of a willingness of consumers to switch consoles following an increase in games prices.” That customers have the option to switch over to the Xbox or a pickup a Nintendo Switch was enough to prevent Sony from strong arming customers with inflated pricing.

Interestingly, the availability of physical games played a role in the tribunal’s decision. It noted that “physical games as likely to be important substitutes for digital PlayStation games which suggested that a SSNIP for digital games would result in material switching by digital users to a physical channel.”

PlayStation 5 DualSense Controller.
PlayStation 5 DualSense Controller. Image: Sony.

However, as the tribunal was working toward its final judgment, Sony announced that it was no longer going to be supporting physical game releases beyond the end of 2027. It could be that a similar lawsuit brought forth in the future would be more likely to go in the plaintiff’s favor with game discs no longer available. This might give Sony pause on its decision to phase out physical game releases, as their existence could be legally advantageous in similar cases down the line.

Additionally, the tribunal closed the door to third-party stores becoming available on PlayStation consoles. It found that it would be too costly for Sony to implement the necessary changes, which could potentially lead to security vulnerabilities and worse performance for customers.

While Sony will be pleased with this outcome, it’s not out of the woods on this issue just yet. It’s still facing similar lawsuits in other part of the world that are currently underway.
Alan Velasco

Alan Velasco

When Alan isn’t watching his favorite streamers on Twitch he’s writing about tech, gaming and cybersecurity.
 
Opinions and content posted by HotHardware contributors are their own.