"6th and 7th grade have cameras. This kid looks like they're editing their MySpace page...they don't even realize that we're watching. I always like to mess with them and take a picture...nine times out of ten they duck out of the way, then they shut down and get to work," Ackerman said. "I think kids know what is expected of them but they also want to do all their other things and they feel that as long as they're doing their work there's nothing wrong with them chatting, looking at themselves in the mirror, as long as it gets done in X amount of time that they have."
Ackerman's comments are drawing a great deal of attention in the wake of the Lower Merion case but the two situations are different enough to warrant separate examination. At IS 339, the emphasis is apparently on prodding students to get back school work, not on using the webcam (allegedly) to provide proof of inappropriate behavior. The remote observation we see on camera is also occurring during school hours, when both laptop and student are on school property. Finally, it's not clear if the parents and students of IS 339 are aware that the school-issued laptops can be monitored remotely.
The staff and administrators at IS 339 deserve a great deal of credit for turning the school around as significantly as they have in such a short time, but issues like this drive home the need to create laptop remote viewing policies that allow the school to achieve its own goals (ensuring that systems are used appropriately, keeping students on-task) without fundamentally violating student privacy. These two goals are not necessarily in conflict. It would be a step in the right direction to establish review policies that ensure no group of students is being monitored by a teacher or administrator whose opinion of said student could be impacted by anything the student might reveal to a friend (or even another teacher) during a supposedly private chat.
|HotHardware EVGA Tegra Note Tablet...||175|
|Assassin's Creed 4 Bogs Down On The PC,...||12|
|Say What? Facebook Can See What You Type...||11|
|Meta Pro Glasses Claim To Deliver Iron...||10|
|No More Woof Translates Dog Thoughs into...||9|
|Apple’s Innovative Cylindrical Mac Pro...||9|
|Apple iPad mini with Retina Display...||9|