Boston University Teaches Patent Trolling 101, Sues Apple, Amazon and Samsung

rated by 0 users
This post has 3 Replies | 0 Followers

Top 10 Contributor
Posts 26,492
Points 1,196,580
Joined: Sep 2007
News Posted: Wed, Jul 3 2013 8:17 PM
Boston University is a prestigous, research-oriented university that can claim a number of famous alumni. Unfortunately, one of the classes it's added in recent months is aimed at a demographic that's been under increasing fire in the United States -- the humble patent troll. BU sued Samsung in April, Amazon in June, and as of yesterday, has added Apple to the mix. The non-profit university has asked that each company be banned from selling pretty much anything, and wants a share of the profits on devices that have been sold.

The patent in question is 5,686,738 (the '738 patent) which describes a method of bonding a thin layer of gallium nitride over a crystal lattice. It was filed in 1995 and granted in 1997 to one Professor Theodore Moustakas. A secondary patent, brought up in some cases, was granted to Moustakas in 2003. The first patent only has a few years left before expiration, which is apparently what inspired Boston University to start suing everyone. BU started with a few small LED manufacturers but has moved on to bigger prey, and is now attempting to block the shipment of virtually every major smartphone and tablet vendor in the United States.

Furthermore, BU has gone after distributors, rather than focusing on the large electronics companies themselves. Samsung's lawyer Jeffrey Lerner submitted a letter he received from BU counsel Michael Shore, as evidence. The letter reads:
Samsung's customers and distributors are next. Unless Samsung stipulates to include customer US imports and sales in damages (or settles), BU is going to sue every single distributor and customer who imports a GaN infringing sensors.[sic].

A Bridge Too Far

On the one hand, what we have here are real patents that describe specific ways of building a product and they're held by an engineer, not a Patent Assertion Entity (PAE) with no research experience or work in the appropriate industry. This is the sort of situation patents are supposed to protect, right?

Actually, no. Even if we assume that Moustakas' patents will hold up under examination, this is the sort of scenario that's turned the patent business into such a litigious mess. Boston University, having recently discovered that it has the rights to this patent, has also discovered that a number of electronics companies use this method of creating displays. With just a few years to go before the patent expires, clearly the only thing the "non-profit*" school can do is sue everyone, everywhere, all at once.

No, Boston University isn't a PAE, but it's acting like one. The patent system in America has broken, the costs of defending against false patent claims is skyrocketing. Why is this happening? Because it's hugely lucrative.

Payments to patent trolls have increased by nearly 6x over just six years. Clearly, Boston University is hoping for several huge payouts from the major electronics and retail firms. Hopefully it finds itself facing the Billy Goats Gruff instead.

* -- When your endowment sits at $1.1B and your President is paid more than one million a year, I think we can question the "non-profit" status.
  • | Post Points: 50
Top 150 Contributor
Posts 619
Points 5,260
Joined: Dec 2011

I am applying to patent ideas.

  • | Post Points: 5
Top 150 Contributor
Posts 501
Points 4,625
Joined: Dec 2011
Location: centennial park az
AKnudson replied on Thu, Jul 4 2013 12:30 AM

Matthew has a great point. What does a patent troll have to lose......... besides a 10-20 thousand per patent apllication. (assuming my rent-a-lawyer wasn't lying to me.)

Patents are to protect intellectual property. However our patent system needs a major overhaul. we need patent divisions that handle certain fields, guideline on what is and isn't a patent able idea.

Patents are abused by patent trolls and completely walked over by large companies. hundreds of billions in revenue is being sucked out of companies due to this ridiculous system.

  • | Post Points: 5
Top 200 Contributor
Posts 354
Points 3,075
Joined: Aug 2012
Location: Canada

I love the little troll doll graph XD

Keep the humor coming in the articles guys, it makes me want to come back and read more than I already do :P

PC Specs:

  • AMD Athlon 64 x2 6400+  Cooled by a Cooler Master Hyper 212 Plus (push-pull)
  • 2GB DDR2
  • MSI Radeon HD 6450 2GB
  • Stock Dell motherboard
  • 250Gb HDD
  • XFX Pro Core edition 650W PSU
  • Stock Dell inspiron case


  • | Post Points: 5
Page 1 of 1 (4 items) | RSS