Lenovo ThinkStation S20 Workstation Review - HotHardware

Lenovo ThinkStation S20 Workstation Review

2 thumbs up

SPECViewPerf 10
Workstation OpenGL Performance - www.spec.org




SolidWorks SW-02



Once again, the S20 totally shines in the first three tests on this page. In the ugnx test, the S20 performs very similarly to the other system with the Quadro FX 4800, but the ATI FireGL cards are obviously more optimized for this workload as they mop the floor with the NVIDIA cards.

Article Index:

0
+ -

The Quadro FX 4800 is a mainstream equivalent of a GeForce GTX 260. Yes, that is some serious horsepower in a workstation. Still kinda confused what a workstation, but know enough to see that I don't want to use this as a gaming rig, lol.

0
+ -

And just about any serious workstation provider will allow you to employ dual FX 4800 cards (or even two FX 5800), as well a two Xeon 5500 series cards, and require the appropriate memory configurations.

0
+ -

Why didn't you include other workstations for your comparisons? Is this your deliberate choice or ignorance?

Xi, Colfax, Polywell, Puget -- and Dell, HP.

Please do a serious workstation review!

0
+ -

hko45 - we didn't have other workstations available, but that's a good idea for the future.

0
+ -

Your article gives the impression that Lenovo is a major (significant) workstation player and the box you're reviewing is a good representation of the workstation offerings. At the very least, you might have put your review in a proper context by listing some other workstation builders as places your readers can do their own research.

BTW: a good review might be to compare configurators at different sites. As far as workstations are concerned, the HDD selection section at Dell is a real weak spot. For example: This is what I want (dream) my HDD setup to look like: HD1 - two SSD (SLC) in Raid 0 for OS & programs, HD2 is a moderately fast drive (scratch disk) and HD3 - (4) 1-1.5 TB SATAs in Raid 10 for storage. (Yes, this is optimozed for PhotoShop)  You can't do that on Dell's site, while the Colfax site lets you do that (close, anyway). Money wise, I think Xi, Colfax, & Polywell have the best value for workstations.

 

0
+ -

I believe Dell and HP are the biggest workstation providers by far, but Lenovo is one of the bigger names after that (thanks in large part to its IBM heritage). I had intended to mention at least Dell and HP as other workstation vendors, but I forgot to do so. I saw one of the new HP Z workstations in person several months ago, and it was one of the coolest machines I've ever seen. The design is incredible...the tool-less features are awesome.

I have heard of most of the other vendors you mentioned. I'm not sure how other companies work, but I work for a pretty big company and I'd have a hard time selling lesser known (unknown to most people) names to my management. I work for a company with 2,000-3,000 workstations for engineers, and I'm 99.9% sure I'd get a few raised eyebrows for suggesting Xi, Colfax, Polywell or Puget workstations over Lenovo, Dell or HP (we use Dell's by the way for workstations and Lenovo for portable workstations). We have to consider price, support processes and ISV certifications before many other factors.

Good feedback on the configurators. That is an important thing for buyers to be aware of. But, another thing to keep in mind is that Dell may work wih you to configure your workstation as you mentioned.

0
+ -

While Dell & HP may be the largest (units or $$) (in the tradition of the super gaming machine), you might ask which vendors are providing really top-end workstations for video, photo, & design houses. I.e., who are the elite workstation vendors? I still like Xi or Colfax here.

As for configurators, yes I expect Dell to tell me that they can configure my HD setup the way I want once I start talking to a sales person. But I want a tool that helps me compare comparable systems without having to get to the sales pitch. And lest you think I was wholly enamored of Colfax's configurator, it falls down in the area of memory selection. It's tool allows you to choose just about any combination of modules, so much so that you can really mess up your system. (Give me my memory options in matched increments of 3GB; double if using dual CPUs -- enough versatility without letting you screw up too much).

As for Lenovo, once I heard the rumors about the possibility of planting hardware malware, I swore off having anything to do with a mainland China vendor.

 

 

 

Login or Register to Comment
Post a Comment
Username:   Password: