Android vs. Windows Phone: The Case For Conversion

Article Index:   
2012 is shaping up to be a major year for mobile operating systems. For those fortunate enough to own a smartphone, these are exciting times. Competition is fierce, and the winner is you. Regardless of which platform you're keen on, you can bet that each of the major players are pushing the others to innovate and improve. In just a few weeks, Apple's Worldwide Developer Conference will kick off. While it remains to be seen if a new MacBook Pro or a new iPhone will launch, one thing is very likely: iOS 6 will be showcased for the first time.

WWDC 2011 was where iOS 5 really got its wings, and Siri was brought into the fold last October. iOS 6 is apt to be the biggest iOS release yet, and as the first full iOS release since the Retina-display enabled iPad hit, it'll probably have quite a bit of iPad-specific tweaks, too.

Google, on the other hand, is poised to showcase the next major revision of Android just weeks later at this year's Google I/O. For Google, it's an interesting beast. Android 5.0 (Jelly Bean) will be the main topic of conversation, right alongside the company's recently-finalized acquisition of Motorola Mobility. To date, we haven't heard a lot about Android 5.0 in terms of features, but Ice Cream Sandwich (Android 4.0) has had a lot of time to mature. Particularly on the Galaxy Nexus, the pure version of ICS is one of the most fluid, visually appealing mobile OSes -- but is it still the best alternative for those who are shying away from the iPhone for one reason or another?

We ask the question because of Windows Phone's recent successes, however mild they may be. Microsoft's Windows Phone 7.5 (Mango) feels like a completely overhauled version of the original WP7 build that shipped with phones like the HD7, Omnia 7 and Samsung Focus. Originally, it felt as if Windows Phone 7 was forced out just in time for the holiday season, but the latest version is a significantly better option. We'll delve deeper on that in a bit. For now, let's look at the existing pros and cons of Android.


One of Google's best decisions was its choice to release the "Nexus" line of devices. These "special" phones run a "pure," un-skinned version of Android. Perhaps not surprisingly, these are also widely regarded as some of the best Android phones to ship. Personally, I've been using Android as my primary mobile OS for the past three years, while still keeping a toe in the water of iOS and Windows Phone (and webOS, while it lasted). If you're looking for compelling reasons to stay planted in the Android universe, here are a few of my favorite Android features:

The Native Gmail App

If you're using Google and aren't using Gmail as your primary mail client, you're missing out. Google created Gmail, and naturally, they created the world's best mobile Gmail client for use exclusively with Android. Only recently, Google created a Gmail app for iOS (iPhone and iPad), but it's little more than a wrapper of the web app. The native Gmail for Android app offers excellent navigation (when it comes to multiple labels, easy archiving, etc.), best-in-class search (on the iOS side, there's really no local storage of recent emails) and an immense amount of control over notifications. Threaded messaging is also top-notch, and since it's woven into the operating system, it's easy to send links from other apps right from your Gmail account.

The Booming Google Play Market

Despite renaming it from Android Market (completely understandable) to Google Play (a little fuzzy), Android's home for apps is large and wildly popular. The amount of apps available to Android users is mind-boggling at this point, and the growth is showing no signs of slowing. Recent estimates peg the app count at around half a million. Google Play has everything from games to productivity to VoIP apps -- you name it, and you can bet that someone has probably submitted an app for it. And with Google's overall ecosystem encompassing hundreds of different devices spread all over the world, there's a hugely diverse developer landscape working on new programs. Yes, fragmentation is a real issue, but by and large the app quality is fantastic considering just how many new programs are being submitted each day.

Google Maps Navigation

Outside of search and email, Google also tends to be really good at mapping, geo-location and navigation. Google Maps has become the de facto guidance service for many, and if you travel any amount at all, you'll certainly love this app. Again, it's an Android exclusive. Other platforms certainly have Maps, but none of them have built-in turn-by-turn voice navigation. With Google Maps Navigation, you can have an actual voice guide you in a vehicle, on foot or even via public transport. Best of all, it's totally free, forever, and Google updates its maps far more frequently than that Garmin or TomTom that's collecting dust in your closet. Your closest bet on iOS? Purchasing a third-party app that probably doesn't integrate as well with iOS.

Google Drive

Noticing a trend here? Google's suite of Android applications are stellar. The recently-unveiled Google Drive takes the place of Google Docs, and it also adds a sophisticated cloud element that will make Dropbox users feel right at home. Any document created or edited within Drive will show up on any other browser, and any photos or PDFs you've hosted in your Drive cloud account will be accessible on your Android device. Yes, an iOS Drive app is coming, but much like Maps and Latitude on iOS, the Android version will almost certainly be superior given that Google can weave it into Android's underpinnings.

Customization possibilities
Yes, this is nerdy, but if you're reading this, chances are you'll care. Google's Android platform is without question the easiest to customize, and the options are numerous. A highly populated forum by the name of xda-developers is flush with Android skins, mods, hacks and ROMs, enabling users to install all manners of Android on their phone. If you aren't totally pleased with what Google's giving you, chances are CyanogenMod or other custom ROM will do the trick. You'll also be able to add new widgets, install underground applications, run all sorts of metrics and tests -- it's a tinkerer's playground. If you're into hacking, Android remains the best mobile platform for that kind of modification.



Now that we've discussed some of the pros of Android, let's take a look at some of the downsides.

Battery life
Outside of a select few devices (like the DROID RAZR Maxx), most Android phones have below average battery life. Particularly if you're a power user who tends to keep a lot running in the background, or if you take advantage of Google Maps Navigation. Keeping the nav going and the display on can zap a smartphone's battery in just a few hours, from a full charge. Thankfully, the accessory market is huge, and it's not too tough to find extended batteries for most major Android smartphones. Of course, dealing with the extra bulge isn't something that some folks will like.

Design
For those that are keen on continuity and aesthetics, Android may be somewhat of a letdown. Yes, it's fairly polished, but most would argue that iOS and Windows Phone are far sexier platforms. Android is the most customizable, but it also feels a bit bolted-together in parts because of that. There's rarely a uniform look -- skins can make it look like anything -- and there's something of a cacophony of design ideas going on at any given time.

Pricing
Strangely, prices for Android smartphones have been rising. Many LTE-equipped Android phones hit the market at $199 - 299 on contract, which is about $100 more than similarly equipped Windows Phone products and the 3G-enabled iPhone 4S. Yes, it's possible to get slightly dated Android phones for less, but somewhat higher pricing is certainly something to consider.

Now, onto Windows Phone...
 

Related content

Comments

Comments
RTietjens 2 years ago

Moving from the open Android ecosystem to Microsoft's buggy, clunky, proprietary and closed WP ecosystem strikes me as a form of masochism; I can't imagine any technically-literate person doing that voluntarily. I own a couple of Android devices, have owned others, and work with Android, Blackberry, and WP devices (and have extensively tested Windows 8, which is arguably WP on desktops). Nothing could convince me to give up Android on my own phone, especially after having suffered with Blackberry and WP.

Dave_HH 2 years ago

Agreed Dan and RT, if you're thinking of WP7 or 7.5 as being a kin to W8 on the desktop, you're way off the mark. WP7.5 is a true handset OS and W8 really only excels for touch devices like tablets and maybe convertible notebooks and touch driven all-in-ones like HP's TouchSmart series for example.

CVoller 2 years ago

@RTietjens

Buggy and clunky? I can't count how many Android devices have frozen, rebooted, or just shut off in my hands or when someone was trying to do something as simple as showing me a photo they took. How long did it take, and how many cores were added just to get an Android phone to scroll, zoom in and out smoothly? Since owning my Focus S in late 2011, it has froze on me a total of 2 times while using trial apps, never rebooted itself, and never just shut off for no given reason, and always scrolls and works the way it should every day. Not to mention have an Android last 2 days on one charge like a WP7 can. Hell, a friend's LG Android drained his battery to nothing in less than 2 hours because some app decided to keep running in the background. It's fine if you don't like them, but don't make up crap because of it. They work great for people who want a smart phone that acts like the same smart phone every time they unlock it.

Dave_HH 2 years ago

RT, Windows Phone 7.5 just works for the average Joe. Have you experienced WP7 on a handset for any length of time? Many times there are fewer strokes to do various tasks versus Android and the UI is slick and fast. It's not tweakable or as accessible under the hood as Android but it's no joke. It's a solid handset OS.

Dan_R 2 years ago

I have to agree with Dave on this. I've been using WP 7.5 since November 2011 when the HTC Titan came out for ATT. I have to say, the phone is solid. While most users don't understand how incredible this OS is, as a developer, it's beyond anything that Droid could put out. First, there's so many things that are built right into the search, like, music search, barcode, text scanning, text translating.. Instagram-type app.. Then the FB integration with your contacts.. Instant posting and sharing.. I had a Samsung Captivate. The only things I miss on that phone is swype and Citrix. With my WinPhone, I don't need to have an App Killer. All the apps on the windows phone (this is an OS Feature.. not an app thing) It prevents applications from running in the background. It puts them into hibernation mode. On my samsung, I'd have to go in every few hours to kill apps or my battery would die. Just these few reasons make the phone solid. The only faults I have is that it only works with Unified access gateway servers for VPN (F That btw), and there's no Flash integration. But I can live without it. I have a droid tablet i use for connecting into the office. I'm not a total MS Fanboy, but I gotta give credit where credit is due. The games rock, the video rocks, the Exchange integration is phenominal, and I love the email interface for all my personal email accts.. And the live panels on the front are great.

lumpaywk 2 years ago

"you're considering future access to Drive, Maps, etc., you're probably going to be out of luck" - This may be true but if you go with Nokia then you have Nokia Drive that uses Nokia Maps. This is actually much better than googlemaps as they are more complete ie google maps sometimes misses out entire rural areas just because it has not benefit to there advertising. Nokia Maps have been used by other mapping companies and are extremly good. Plus soon they will be made available as a paid app to other windows phones though why you would go away from Nokia i would not know.

lonnierenda 2 years ago

Mr. Willington,

As a user of Google Apps (gmail, calendar, contacts, docs, etc) would you recommend the Windows Phone? I use google apps constantly. I have an android tablet and phone, but am interested in converting to Windows 7.5 (and Windows 8 on tablets/PC when available), but I am afraid I will lose the functionality with Google that my Android phone give me. It will not be an issue on Win 8 tablets running intel chips/Win 8 Pro, as you can just use chrome or the internet, but it will be on Win 8 arm tablets/Win 8 RT and these phones.

What are your thoughts on this topic?

Post a Comment
or Register to comment